Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[E Z]

There’s got to be a sticky here somewhere, but I’ve seen so many  people complain about Guichet and Sarin.

As a community, these two butchers should be on a blacklist front and center for everyone to see.

It’s so important to do research on your Doctor, but let’s make it easier for that potential person so they can avoid a nightmare of consequences.

[Skyisthelimit]

Totally agree with you! This could avoid terrible outcomes with future CLL patients.

[184dream]

Agree

[ghkid2019]

Butchers. Take money then do the the bare minimum so you don't die but can't speak out against him since he's the only one you can do anything with now unless you pay another surgeon to fix his issues.

[HarryWang]

Bad Doctors: Guichet, Betz, Sarin, Barinov, Monegal, Janjua, Sringari, Mirzoyan

Risky Newbs: Debiparshad

Overrated for the Money: Lee

Yet to Prove Themselves: Giotikas, Solomin, Buldu

Mixed: Jamal, Yasser

[BelowTheMean]

Bad Doctors: Guichet, Betz, Sarin, Barinov, Monegal, Janjua, Sringari, Mirzoyan

Risky Newbs: Debiparshad

Overrated for the Money: Lee

Yet to Prove Themselves: Giotikas, Solomin, Buldu

Mixed: Jamal, Yasser

What’s the difference between “risky newbs” and “yet to prove themselves”?

[ghkid2019]

What’s the difference between “risky newbs” and “yet to prove themselves”?

Debiparshad is doing limb lengthening solely for profit. He does not even do deformity correction unlike the other surgeons in yet to prove themselves who have established records in limb lengthening for medical reasons and only recently started cosmetic elective surgeries.

[hanshi]

As a general rule you should avoid doctors who use their own implants. There is no control whatsoever for these implants and you can be sure they will never admit their product had a defect.
Products like "Betzbone" and " Guichet Nail" for example.

[marathonrunner]

Add to your bad list: Dr Singh from singapore, he trained under Dr Betz

Feel free to look up my posts if you want to know why he should be under the bad list

[California2]

Yet to Prove Themselves: Giotikas, Solomin, Buldu

I usually do not comment on these type of posts; yet, to characterize Professor Solomin as "yet to prove himself" is idiotic.

Solomin is a MD/PhD scientist with more experience than any other limb lengthening surgeon--he has handled more than 10,000 legs and literally wrote the book (twice) on external lengthening (https://www.amazon.com/Leonid-Solomin/e/B0034OAOFA%3Fref=dbs_a_mng_rwt_scns_share.

Please do NOT express opinions on matters for which you plainly have no information.

Professor Solomin's abbreviated biography is below:

Leonid N. Solomin, MD, PhD

Orthopaedic Surgeon
Professor of Orthopaedic Surgery
Leading Researcher, Vreden Russian Research Institute of Traumatology and Orthopedics
Professor of the General Surgery Chair, St. Petersburg State University
Honourable Professor of Russian Ilizarov Scientific Center
Restorative Traumatology and Orthopedics
Kurgan Oblast, 640014 Russia

Biography

EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND AND PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCES

• (1986) graduated with honors from Blagoveshchensky State Medical University
• (1986-1991) post-graduate education, specialization in traumatology and orthopaedics
• (1991-1993) the assistant of Chair of Traumatology and Orthopedics of Blagoveshchensky State Medical University
• (1992) PhD
• (1993-1995) External Fixation Laboratory Researcher at Irkutsky Research Institute of Traumatology and Orthopedics
• (1995-1998) Head of Department of Traumatology and Orthopedics at Irkutsky Region Hospital
• (1996) Doctor of Science
• (1998-2000) Head of Department of External Fixation at Irkutsky Research Institute of Traumatology and Orthopedics
• (2008) Full professor of orthopedic surgery
• (2000-Present): Leading Researcher and Orthopedic Surgeon at Vreden Russian Research Institute of Traumatology and Orthopedics (Saint-Petersburg, Russia). The main field of work is devoted to development, perfection, substantiation and clinical application of external and combined fixation in fractures, non-unions, deformations, defects of long bones and foot, including congenital and infection problems.
• Since (2004-Present) improvement of computer navigation in external fixation (Ortho-SUV Frame)
• (2013-Present Professor of General Surgery Chair, St.Petersburg State University.

Research Interest

His research interest includes: Orthopedics.

Scientific Activities

• Member of ASAMI International
• Member of ASAMI Russia
• Member of AO/ASIF and SICOT

Publications

He as authored over 400 articles and abstracts, 5 monographs, 51 patents of Russia.

[Arcon]

I have always felt that this thread is a bit stupid.

[Skyisthelimit]

Why would you consider this thread to be stupid? From all the diaries in this forum people can have a pretty accurate opinion on which doctors should be considered and which should be discarded. This thread is a way to help new users or users considering CLL, but not decided on the doctor, to get a general idea on some of the doctors out there. I believe it’s an excellent idea and should have been implemented sooner. It might have avoided some tragic outcomes.

[Skyisthelimit]

I do believe that this thread can be drastically improved. Maybe by adding some additional info on the doctors on the list. Stats and whatnot. That would change the current list from a list based on opinions, to a list based on opinions supported by facts.

[184dream]

Mongeal pariharr is bad why plz tell us

[184dream]

So solomin is good who else can you help