May I ask how you evaluated your own pain tolerance ability? What's more decent surgeons will also offer you with best painkillers so it's not necessary for you to make choices.
Not necessarily. Pain management is not always a field of great concern for all surgeons, who often rely on "one solution fits all" according to their education, personal experience, "likes" and being better updated or not. For example it now seems that NSAIDs are not contra indicated for bone healing (Dr. Assayag).
An excellent surgeon is not allways the best medicine doctor (after all, most of the time, while they operate, they are not doing any other pure doctors"s work: diagnosis, therapeutics, etc). Anaesthesia (and analgesia in a certain extent) are separate branches in medicine. In each important surgery there is an anaesthesiologist making team with the surgeon, and furthermore it's not always the doctor who does the closer follow up of the recovery period (Dr. Giotikas is apparently sometimes seen one time only in Greece each month, Paley is hardly seen, Guichet "commutes" between Milan and London...). In LL it's more usual to be the surgeon, which is often also an orthopedic doctor, to do the follow-up, but the problem is sometimes worse because he/she is many times absent.
Both issues are relevant questions to the doctor before chosing one: his presence after surgery and his approach to pain management.