Limb Lengthening Forum

Limb Lengthening Surgery => Limb Lengthening Doctors => Topic started by: KiloKAHN on July 14, 2014, 03:42:37 PM

Title: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on July 14, 2014, 03:42:37 PM
General information about Dr Suhas Shah of Ashwinii Accident Hospital, located in Mumbai, India. Contact for specific information and latest updates.
Note: Please refer to our disclaimer about the Doctors Directory http://www.limblengtheningforum.com/index.php?topic=55.0 (http://www.limblengtheningforum.com/index.php?topic=55.0)
(http://s5d4.turboimagehost.com/t1/19415861_Dr_Shah.jpg) (http://www.turboimagehost.com/p/19415861/Dr_Shah.jpg.html)

Brief Profile (From Website):
I have been trained in Ilizarov surgery at the world leading centre, under the able guidance of Prof. Dror Palely at University of Maryland Baltmore, U.S.A. I had also been fortunate to work under the guidance of Prof. Cattaneo & Prof. Catagani (who were the first to introduce Prof. Ilizarov from Russia & his technique to rest of the world) at Lecco, Italy. I have been practicing as an orthopaedic surgeon with super specialization in Ilizarov surgery since last 16 years. I'm visiting as an Ilizarov specialist all over Maharacrapra and have done more than 1400 surgeries in this specialty till now. I have been a faculty member during various ilizarov courses & workshops held all over India. We now have a center for total Orthopaedic care under one roof.

Qualifications
M.S. (Ortho), M.B.B.S., FAIS (Germany), Fellow in Ilizarov (USA, Italy), Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon & Specialist in Ilizarov Surgery.

Specialties
Trauma, Ilizarov Fixation for Limb Reconstruction, Limb Lengthening and Deformity Correction, Spine surgery, Arthroscopic surgery, Joint Replacement surgery, Fracture and Accident services, Diabetic foot surgery, Polio and Cerebral Palsy surgery.

Awards & Honors

Why CFIS (Center For Ilizarov Surgery):
More than a 1400 patients from India and the rest of the world have been successfully treated here over the last 16 years. All modern techniques of limb lengthening such as the Ilizarov; Lengthening Over Nails as well as fully implantable nails are used here to tailor the treatment for the individual patient's needs. The complete range of Ilizarov Techniques is practiced here to perfection. Success rates are very high even for complex problems. Several new operations have been designed to help those suffering from Poliomyelitis & Club Feet. It is recognized as a referral center for difficult Ilizarov problems and leading Orthopaedic Surgeons in India refer their problem cases here. Failed Ilizarov cases done elsewhere (in India or anywhere else in the world) are rectified here.

Personalized care and attention is given to all patients. Patients have very comfortable and spacious fully furnished rooms and are provided freshly cooked meals from a special kitchen with ultra-filtered drinking water. The Director of the Center has the unique perspective of being trained by the best - Prof. Dr. Dror Paley, MD, FRCSC, in a Fellowship at the Maryland Center for Limb Lengthening & Reconstruction, USA & Prof. Cataneo & Catagni from Lecco, Italy.

Hospital Services:
Ilizarov (Russian) Surgery, Fracture & accident treatment, Joint Replacement Surgery, Spine Surgery, Arthroscopy Shoulder & knee, Hand Surgery, Ilizarov Angioplasty, Diabetic Foot Management, Physiotherapy, Osteoporosis Detection Centre (BMD test), X-Ray & Sonography, Whole Body Color Doppler, Portable Sonography & Color Doppler, Pathology Collection Centre.

Limb Lengthening Methods:
Cosmetic lengthening of the tibias is recommended a maximum of 7.5 cm with external fixation, LON, or LATP. Internal lengthening with the Precice 2 is also available for both tibias and femurs.

Pricing:
Estimate for bilateral tibial lengthening with external fixation device is $8,000 USD and $9,000 USD for LON or LATP. Internal Precice is $30,000 USD for the nails in addition to surgical costs and doctor fees. Price covers surgery and initial stay at the hospital before discharge.

Accommodation Options:
International patients will have to stay at a hotel after discharge from the hospital, preferably for the duration of the procedure or until distraction is completed.

Contact Information:

Website
www.suhasshah.com (http://www.suhasshah.com)
www.ashwiniihospital.com (http://www.ashwiniihospital.com)

E-Mail
drshahsuhas@gmail.com

Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Ganesh Apartment, Opposite Sh!taladevi Temple, Mahim (west), Mumbai, 400016    
Phone: +91 (022) 24455155
Mobile: +91 9322235042
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: ChrisIsaak on July 15, 2014, 09:32:53 AM
What a great name for a hospital  :D
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on July 15, 2014, 11:43:45 PM
What a great name for a hospital  :D

Heck yes it is.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: LifesTooShort on July 25, 2014, 05:51:23 AM
Okay so I just got off the phone with Dr. Shah (his assistant answered at first and, ironically, speaks not a word of English lol).
Dr. Shah states that the total cost of lengthening with the Precise 2 nail, including all hospital fees and one week's stay in the hospital, is $40,000USD (FORTY THOUSAND DOLLARS!). He also gives his patients the option of going home (in my case Canada) to lengthen, returning to India only to have the nail locked and to return the transponder. Of course there is the additional surgery to remove the nails 1 to 2 years after the initial surgery (the cost of which I stupidly forgot to ask him). I think this is great news! He claims he has "done this procedure before", but I wasn't able to obtain a figure as to how many times. I'm doing my tibias in January, but if this price remains the same in a year or two (wishful thinking), I'll be going there for my femurs.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Taller on July 25, 2014, 08:09:31 PM
How much does he charge for physio for femoral lengthening?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Taller on July 25, 2014, 08:12:10 PM
He also gives his patients the option of going home (in my case Canada) to lengthen, returning to India only to have the nail locked and to return the transponder.

Be very careful with this. Femur lengthening requires extensive physio and most physiotherapists have no clue how to handle therapy for cosmetic femoral lengthening. You could easily waste your money and chances for a decent/fast recovery.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: LifesTooShort on July 28, 2014, 04:53:59 AM
Be very careful with this. Femur lengthening requires extensive physio and most physiotherapists have no clue how to handle therapy for cosmetic femoral lengthening. You could easily waste your money and chances for a decent/fast recovery.

I have no intention of travelling anywhere to lengthen other than the city in which I had the surgery done. I'm simply passing on the information I was given. I agree with you though; leaving the country of the hospital in which you had your surgery is unadvisable. As I stated earlier, it's a premature conversation for me, as my tibia surgery is booked for January, after which femurs would be a mere consideration.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on July 28, 2014, 05:51:52 AM
Okay so I just got off the phone with Dr. Shah (his assistant answered at first and, ironically, speaks not a word of English lol).
Dr. Shah states that the total cost of lengthening with the Precise 2 nail, including all hospital fees and one week's stay in the hospital, is $40,000USD (FORTY THOUSAND DOLLARS!). He also gives his patients the option of going home (in my case Canada) to lengthen, returning to India only to have the nail locked and to return the transponder. Of course there is the additional surgery to remove the nails 1 to 2 years after the initial surgery (the cost of which I stupidly forgot to ask him). I think this is great news! He claims he has "done this procedure before", but I wasn't able to obtain a figure as to how many times. I'm doing my tibias in January, but if this price remains the same in a year or two (wishful thinking), I'll be going there for my femurs.

He charges approximately $1,000 USD for frame removal with exfix or rod removal for LON. Shouldn't be much different from nail removal with Precice.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: LifesTooShort on August 03, 2014, 10:38:30 AM
He charges approximately $1,000 USD for frame removal with exfix or rod removal for LON. Shouldn't be much different from nail removal with Precice.

This makes sense. Me thinks he may possibly be a good, affordable option, provided we can get a legitimate diary or two going and a reasonable rate for lodging.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on September 07, 2014, 04:59:06 AM
I have to give Dr. Shah a big thumbs up

Fixed my ballerina, took frames off, suggested cast instead of plating...   daily pt,  twice a day.... staff cry helpful, drs speak english, etc

I've been very satisfied thus far
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: ShortyMcShort on September 10, 2014, 08:56:15 AM
$40,000 is indeed cheap, but you still need to add in physio, accommodation and food for roughly 3 months if doing Precice 2. So far the cheapest Precice 2 package is Dr Birkholtz $52,000 approx. This could work out to be cheaper
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on September 10, 2014, 08:58:53 AM
$40,000 is indeed cheap, but you still need to add in physio, accommodation and food for roughly 3 months if doing Precice 2. So far the cheapest Precice 2 package is Dr Birkholtz $52,000 approx. This could work out to be cheaper

You can find good hotels with rates of $1,500 a month. Physio probably wouldn't be expensive. I haven't been charged a dime for physiotherapy with Dr Parihar. Food here is really cheap. I spend maybe 3 or 4 bucks a day on it.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Greek-Semidget on September 10, 2014, 10:29:43 PM
This guy sounds to have experience, well and 6.400 euros is cheap.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Doflamingo on October 03, 2014, 07:40:06 PM
Does anyone recommend him?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Adriano on October 25, 2014, 02:23:03 AM
I want to do 5.5cm with monorail (external only) with Dr Shah in the next 3 weeks.

I want him to do my tibias because I intend to get him to do my internal Femur with precise after soon after (around 6 months after tibia surgery).

Can you guys let me know what I need to do to get a medical visa for this procedure?

 
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on October 25, 2014, 02:30:01 AM
The easiest way to obtain a Medical Treatment visa is to send an e-mail to a hospital you are considering for surgery and tell them that you desire to have CLL and wish to have a Medical Treatment visa for entry. The hospital should have no problem writing a letter addressed to your nearest Indian Embassy/Consulate General of India Office and e-mailing it back for you to include with other documents to send in to the appropriate visa application center. The Embassy of India has given the new contract for providing Visa applications to Cox & Kings Global Services, and based on their website it looks like their process is pretty straightforward.

http://www.in.ckgs.us/visa/type-of-visa/medical-visa.crapml (http://www.in.ckgs.us/visa/type-of-visa/medical-visa.crapml)
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Ajax2thousand20 on October 27, 2014, 07:59:26 AM
So wait, with accommodation (food therapy place to stay), what would the grand total be?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Taller on October 27, 2014, 05:23:52 PM
I wonder just how weight bearing the metal plates used in the LATP option are.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: TRS on November 10, 2014, 08:40:10 AM
I wonder just how weight bearing the metal plates used in the LATP option are.
I'll call him up today and ask him whether he would perform LOP and if he would recommend LOP over LATP. The scarring doesn't seem too bad with LOP and I don't mind partial weight bearing once the fixators are off and plates are locked.

^
I called him and he does perform LOP. Partial weight bearing is recommended after plates are locked in. He also mentioned that scars will be minimal.

Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Adriano on November 10, 2014, 11:47:08 AM
Just when I am about to finalise my trip to India I here about the LOP thing.

it looks very interesting :D

study showed that the LATP plates had tendency to bend but they never disclosed the weight of the patients who suffered this problem.

Some one ask the Doctor if they could double plate to increase stability and weight bearing ability.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on November 10, 2014, 09:55:43 PM
That's one of the funny differences between Dr Shah and Dr Parihar that me wonder how two doctors who were fellows under Dr Paley could have such contrasting views on something. Dr Shah seems quite confident in bilateral plate fixation being a good idea but Dr Parihar is totally against bilateral plate fixation for cosmetic patients. Interesting.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: iwanttobetall on November 13, 2014, 10:08:17 AM
Ok as Mitkovic doesn't even pick up the phone... I'm considering Dr. Shah.

But then I'll need to find another person for femur lengthening  :-\
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: ReadRothbard on December 08, 2014, 06:27:09 PM
How does weight-bearing work with internal PRECICE? I'm probably going to be at least 185 lbs by the time my turn at LL comes around, so will that be enough to be on crutches with the nails inside me?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: TomD on December 21, 2014, 02:57:12 PM
This guy seems to know what he is doing, and the price is right.

He doesnt do femurs?  :o
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: afonso on December 21, 2014, 09:57:55 PM
How does weight-bearing work with internal PRECICE? I'm probably going to be at least 185 lbs by the time my turn at LL comes around, so will that be enough to be on crutches with the nails inside me?

Currently Precice II is partial weight bear max of 150LB you will need to use a walker.  There are talks of a new Precice coming that can handle full weight bear past 200. 
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on December 23, 2014, 07:40:06 PM
This guy seems to know what he is doing, and the price is right.

He doesnt do femurs?  :o

He also does femur lengthening.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Ajax2thousand20 on December 23, 2014, 09:15:32 PM
If I do Precice I think Birkholtz is the better foot forward unless Shah will let you lengthen and do PT from home. Because with expenses and food it would probably be more if not the same as Birkholtz.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on December 23, 2014, 09:40:24 PM
If I do Precice I think Birkholtz is the better foot forward unless Shah will let you lengthen and do PT from home. Because with expenses and food it would probably be more if not the same as Birkholtz.

It should come out a little cheaper than Dr Birkholtz, but the difference isn't that large. If you stay in a hotel for four months it should cost around $46,000 USD with Dr Shah.

Basing this off of my roughly $1,500 a month expense of hotel + food while staying in Mumbai and adding that on top of Dr Shah's $40,000 price for Precice internals.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Ajax2thousand20 on December 23, 2014, 09:56:25 PM
It should come out a little cheaper than Dr Birkholtz, but the difference isn't that large. If you stay in a hotel for four months it should cost around $46,000 USD with Dr Shah.

Basing this off of my roughly $1,500 a month expense of hotel + food while staying in Mumbai and adding that on top of Dr Shah's $40,000 price for Precice internals.

Yeah cool thanks. I think I'll probably have to do LON and ask to do PT in the USA when the frames are removed just to leave a strange country. I may get lucky next year and have enough to do Precice but not gonna get my hopes up.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Thegosis on January 27, 2015, 12:29:41 PM
Hot of the press here is a message from Dr Shah: "Nail u are interested will cost u
Around US dollar 50000 and other cost will be another 10 -12 k US dollar...
If you are interested, nail will be ready in 5 wk time and we can go ahead"

The 10k cost for surgery I knew about but the 50k(!) to Ellipse for the nail. WTF? It says 30k at the beginning of this thread which is barely a month ago. Certainly going to query this.

Who else has been quoted? Isn't it 30k also through Dr Parihar also in the same city?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KrP1 on January 27, 2015, 01:11:54 PM
send an email to Dr. parihar asking him the Price
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Thegosis on January 27, 2015, 03:52:59 PM
How can we have it said just before christmas thar surgery plus nails equals 40k and now a month later nails alone are alone  50k. No way can that add up
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on January 27, 2015, 06:30:48 PM
How can we have it said just before christmas thar surgery plus nails equals 40k and now a month later nails alone are alone  50k. No way can that add up

That doesn't add up at all unless Ellipse suddenly shot up their price. As Kirp1 said, send an e-mail to another doctor and see what he quotes you. Then you'll know for sure if Dr Shah is inflating the price or not. I'd send an e-mail to Dr Birkholtz asking what the cost of the nails would be, as he's used them already. He hasn't updated his package price of $52,000 total for Precice femurs, so...

Maybe send Dr Parihar an e-mail too if you're set on India.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Thegosis on January 29, 2015, 04:22:57 AM
Well I've purchased airfare credit with an airline that services Asia. That was in reliance on a figure of $30k which I have no doubt you got directly from Dr Shah. But if I have to consider South Africa because of one doctors sudden price hike for no special justification then that sucks and now I have the airfares I don't need.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on January 29, 2015, 04:28:01 AM
Well I've purchased airfare credit with an airline that services Asia. That was in reliance on a figure of $30k which I have no doubt you got directly from Dr Shah. But if I have to consider South Africa because of one doctors sudden price hike for no special justification then that sucks and now I have the airfares I don't need.

Well if the nails are still $30,000 USD then you can get Precice femurs with Dr Parihar for around $43,000 - $45,000. It's worth checking in with him so your airline credit won't be wasted. I highly doubt there was a $20,000 USD price hike from Ellipse all of a sudden.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: ReadRothbard on January 29, 2015, 04:39:14 AM
Well if the nails are still $30,000 USD then you can get Precice femurs with Dr Parihar for around $43,000 - $45,000. It's worth checking in with him so your airline credit won't be wasted. I highly doubt there was a $20,000 USD price hike from Ellipse all of a sudden.

My guess is that it was most likely a typo on Dr. Shah's part.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on January 29, 2015, 04:53:59 AM
Let's hope so. It would suck if he was purposely inflating the price.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: ReadRothbard on January 29, 2015, 05:07:03 AM
Let's hope so. It would suck if he was purposely inflating the price.

This is a little off topic and kind of mean, but doesn't Dr. Shah have kind of a funny looking face? Look up some of his picture on google images. You might laugh.  ;D
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Thegosis on January 29, 2015, 09:11:23 AM
Lol wut RR? Is it doing wrong to channel Freddie Mercury?

Seriously, however, the good doctor has allayed my cost concerns with his most recent message which was:

"Dear Dave,
There is good news .Indian company sent me the new costing and with recent mail the cost is coming to US $ 30000 plus taxes appro 5%
company might take deposit for magnetic device to be used during lengthening as you finish lengthening and you return the device they will return it..
pl let me know if you want to transfer money in bank account of the company i can forward the details to you
it will take 5 wk for getting nail"

I look forward to meeting the man early-to-mid March.

'cos weeeeee are the chaaampions my friennnd  :)
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on January 29, 2015, 09:16:31 AM
Great news. Keep us posted when you get there.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: ReadRothbard on January 29, 2015, 05:11:20 PM
Lol wut RR? Is it doing wrong to channel Freddie Mercury?

Seriously, however, the good doctor has allayed my cost concerns with his most recent message which was:

"Dear Dave,
There is good news .Indian company sent me the new costing and with recent mail the cost is coming to US $ 30000 plus taxes appro 5%
company might take deposit for magnetic device to be used during lengthening as you finish lengthening and you return the device they will return it..
pl let me know if you want to transfer money in bank account of the company i can forward the details to you
it will take 5 wk for getting nail"

I look forward to meeting the man early-to-mid March.

'cos weeeeee are the chaaampions my friennnd  :)

Lol good to know about the cost, btw.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on February 01, 2015, 01:01:54 AM
regarding dr shah

i gotta say he seems to be a good dr as far as surgical technique

my right achilles and ankle equinus were fixed perfectly... the scar even looks amazing

the left scar was worse but is now lloking better... i can also say that the numbness has almost entiirely went away, just as he said..He definitely did not cut the nerve,just like he   reassured me.. my equinus waas so bad that the nerve likely stretched  because my equinus was severe and was corrected acutely, not gradually

 my equinus was very bad btw... my dorsiflexion was  around - 60 degrees..... that is not a typo
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: egocentrical on February 07, 2015, 02:07:13 AM
Is LAPT considered a better option over LON? Just wondering where the extra $1000 comes into play.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KiloKAHN on February 07, 2015, 02:36:27 AM
The extra $1,000 for LON or LATP covers the cost of the nails/plates that wouldn't normally be used for external only.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Alittletooshort on February 16, 2015, 11:38:28 PM
I sent an email to his account weeks ago but he didnĀ“t reply yet, how did you get in touch with him?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Taller on February 16, 2015, 11:53:25 PM
Is LAPT considered a better option over LON? Just wondering where the extra $1000 comes into play.

I also wonder the answer to this. Just how much mobility does LATP allow a patient before complete consolidation?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on March 13, 2015, 02:46:21 PM
i can tell you for sure that the prices have went up


also,  because of shah taking the frames off... i am getting a tibia/fibula osteoplasty to correct my left leg

dr shah  wanted to charge me more for this correction than  i paid for the intial issue he fixed

when i say im getting a tibia/fibula osteoplasty to correct my left leg, i just want to be clear.... i can not anywhere near normal because of the left leg... the valgus, etc.... the right leg is fine

if you have to go to india, go to parihar

Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: ItsMyLife on March 13, 2015, 02:47:48 PM
i can tell you for sure that the prices have went up


also,  because of shah taking the frames off... i am getting a tibia/fibula osteoplasty to correct my left leg

dr shah  wanted to charge me more for this correction than  i paid for the intial issue he fixed

when i say im getting a tibia/fibula osteoplasty to correct my left leg, i just want to be clear.... i can not anywhere near normal because of the left leg... the valgus, etc.... the right leg is fine

if you have to go to india, go to parihar

so ur legs were straight all along after surgery with dr bagirov?

any x-legs or varus or valgus etc, that u had to fix?

did they do frame adjustments in Russia?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on March 13, 2015, 03:05:13 PM
my legs were straight before the surgery

right leg is ok


left is not ok... ill have it corrected by dr rozbruch
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: ItsMyLife on March 13, 2015, 03:08:53 PM
my legs were straight before the surgery

right leg is ok


left is not ok... ill have it corrected by dr rozbruch

so u didn't do any frame adjustments in Russia..?
u basically lengthened a while in Russia, and moved out?
and never came back to the clinic for adjustments?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on March 13, 2015, 03:21:41 PM
i didnt lengthen in russia... they want you out of that hospital pretty fast

Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on March 22, 2015, 02:05:46 PM
do not go to this dr... anything that goes wrong, he will not fix...  you will end up being charged double what you thought your surgery would be



you've been warned
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: heightangel on March 26, 2015, 11:14:50 PM
This happens with all doctors. If they fix the problems they've caused, they don't do it right. I don't trust these moneymakers. It's disgusting.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on March 26, 2015, 11:21:43 PM
i'll repeat it again


do not go to this dr....

have to get my issue resolved june 1st with another dr... because shah made a horrible recommendation... and flat out lied about a few different things
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: ReadRothbard on March 27, 2015, 07:22:40 AM
i'll repeat it again


do not go to this dr....

have to get my issue resolved june 1st with another dr... because shah made a horrible recommendation... and flat out lied about a few different things

Did this happen with you or someone else?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Thegosis on August 29, 2015, 06:53:36 AM
I am going to consult with him on 3 October with a view to surgery within the week (PRECICE 2, internal femurs).
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Taller on August 29, 2015, 03:13:15 PM
I am going to consult with him on 3 October with a view to surgery within the week (PRECICE 2, internal femurs).

Wow, thank you for sharing, and GOOD LUCK! Is your motivation for this second LL still the same as it was last time you considered lengthening your femurs?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on September 21, 2015, 01:00:22 AM
read roth,


im speaking from experience

the entire reason i had to go to barcelona to get leg fixed was because of dr shah


the  or  is filthy btw.... someone should take a photo of that room, and show what you lay down on
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on October 03, 2015, 11:45:29 AM
this dr needs to be removed

all my current issues ultimate are due to this mans negligence

he needs to be removed
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Penguinn on October 03, 2015, 12:24:56 PM
this dr needs to be removed

all my current issues ultimate are due to this mans negligence

he needs to be removed

Can you go into details please? What did he do?

Quote from your diary if you want.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on October 04, 2015, 11:06:46 PM
issues with left leg

he performed achilles surery

took  fixators off way early

also,i have a pic... shah did not perform the surgery on my other leg, then he lied about it... u should see scar compared to right leg... ill need revision

also,  my left has sural damage, so a small part of my outside foot is numb... sural luckily is only a sensory nerve


you should see his op too

then shah ignores me

this guy is a hack

prolonged my recovery. and is the reason for my additional surgeries
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Penguinn on October 05, 2015, 03:06:02 AM
issues with left leg

he performed achilles surery

took  fixators off way early

also,i have a pic... shah did not perform the surgery on my other leg, then he lied about it... u should see scar compared to right leg... ill need revision

also,  my left has sural damage, so a small part of my outside foot is numb... sural luckily is only a sensory nerve


you should see his op too

then shah ignores me

this guy is a hack

prolonged my recovery. and is the reason for my additional surgeries

Sorry to hear about that. Hope you get better. :)
Could you link me to your diary?

Also is Dr. Parihar the only good doctor left in India? Everyone else is controversial now.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: jfk on October 05, 2015, 02:16:41 PM
Sorry to hear about that. Hope you get better. :)
Could you link me to your diary?

Also is Dr. Parihar the only good doctor left in India? Everyone else is controversial now.

I dont understand why people go to India when there are many doctors in other countries with much better reputation and experience. And they are not much more expensive...I just dont get it!
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: OregonMade on October 18, 2015, 02:49:03 AM
Can you name doctors in other countries that are less expensive than indian doctors?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: jaymorgan712 on November 21, 2015, 05:27:31 PM
issues with left leg

he performed achilles surery

took  fixators off way early

also,i have a pic... shah did not perform the surgery on my other leg, then he lied about it... u should see scar compared to right leg... ill need revision

also,  my left has sural damage, so a small part of my outside foot is numb... sural luckily is only a sensory nerve


you should see his op too

then shah ignores me

this guy is a hack

prolonged my recovery. and is the reason for my additional surgeries


And this guy was trained by Dr. Paley? Certainly doesn't seem professional. Are there other patients there that are having the same problem?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: Thegosis on December 29, 2015, 12:04:42 PM
He is a fellow of Dr Dror Paley (now of W Palm Beach, Florida) and also Profs Cattaneo and Catagani, the latter of whom introduced Ilizarov technique to the West at Lecco, Italy. His website reports "I have been practicing as an orthopaedic surgeon with super specialization in ilizarov surgery since last 16 years. I'm visiting as an ilizarov specialist all over Maharacrapra and have done more than 1400 surgeries in this specialty till now."

I have had 5cm successful bilateral lengthening via his Hospital so far with internal PRECICE femur nails and met and talked with his current 50yo patient from the USA who is having Ilizarov tibiae with no regrets about choice of surgeon and the management of his complications. Non-interned ward staff may not speak much English but no-one is a 'hack' at the place I must observe having been an inpatient and then outpatient there from October to December this year.

Lying about actually having performed a certain surgery at all on one leg seems rather audacious when proper documentation and the timely examination of another specialist could expose the fact. Pardon my scepticism but did you think to resort to that?

Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on January 25, 2016, 03:43:41 PM
dr shah has not performed 5 precice   lengthenings

id love to see evidence of this

i dont even think   any dr in india has performed 1

the guy is a flat out liar...  and his hospital  would be able to do business in any 1st world nation...

somone should post photos of his operating room and table
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: crimsontide on March 11, 2016, 04:57:30 AM
do not go this doctor


i have to laugh at thegosis

if you look at thegosis' diary... you will see how dr shah thinks that 2 cows  across the street have special therapeutic qualities that will help you

I'm not making this up.... go have a look


 dr shag screwed up my life  because of his   idea to lengthen my achilles, and  take my frames off way too early

No other dr I've spoken with  thinks he did a good job, or that he should have taken my frames off or lengthened my achilles

im currently trying to fix his negligence.... the "hospital" should be closed
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: ppatient on March 13, 2016, 12:22:52 AM
Dr Shah is to be avoided. Ask American doctors about his and his methods. He sucks.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: 143grazia on October 17, 2016, 01:01:04 AM
I'm really considering to get the surgery from doctor shah now,  because of the fee difference. But he doesn't offer femur LON? Is that it? No femurs for him...  It's a total disgrace of that's it.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: 143grazia on October 17, 2016, 01:07:32 AM
Good morning. I'm planning to get LON for my femur from doctor shah soon.  How much is the estimated cost for this?   I have no problem with not staying in a hotel and just basic lodging.  I got no problem with food either.  And just minimally living in Mumbai. For this,  how much is the estimated cost for the whole process? Need your response alot. Thanks.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: BiggestProblem on October 17, 2016, 08:39:14 AM
Good morning. I'm planning to get LON for my femur from doctor shah soon.  How much is the estimated cost for this?   I have no problem with not staying in a hotel and just basic lodging.  I got no problem with food either.  And just minimally living in Mumbai. For this,  how much is the estimated cost for the whole process? Need your response alot. Thanks.
Use a different doctor. (Maybe Dhawan)
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: 143grazia on October 18, 2016, 11:48:16 AM
Do you have any contact details for this doctor??  Hope he is as cheap as Dr.  Shah...  Anyway, thanks alot.  I need to have the surgery ASAP is what it is
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: BiggestProblem on October 18, 2016, 01:36:20 PM
Do you have any contact details for this doctor??  Hope he is as cheap as Dr.  Shah...  Anyway, thanks alot.  I need to have the surgery ASAP is what it is
He has a thread on the forum.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: nomad13 on April 05, 2019, 01:11:03 PM
Does anyone know much does Dr. Shah charges for LON?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KrP1 on September 16, 2019, 11:18:32 AM
This doctor must be avoided at all cost, I know about patients who had very bad results with him. He must be removed of the forum.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: limewalk on September 16, 2019, 12:05:36 PM
Can you provide more details? There is one diary here of an Australian patient who did his femur lengthening with Dr. Suhas Shah which went uneventfully.
Title: Final result video
Post by: good-nite on December 24, 2019, 03:11:17 PM
"Final result" at 1:52 minute mark in this video

https://youtu.be/cTGfscB0PJg?t=112

"Natural growth & No side effects"

- Dr. Suhas Shah (2:30 mark in the video)
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: InFullStryde on December 24, 2019, 05:14:53 PM
Hmm. Her legs are pointing outward.  Perhaps more physical therapy and she will be good again.   
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: good-nite on December 24, 2019, 06:50:51 PM
She has a deformity. Physical therapy can't fix this.

It is hard to believe the surgeon takes pride in showing this case as a success with "final result" as the heading of the clip. Definitely avoid this guy.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: InFullStryde on December 24, 2019, 06:53:26 PM
I agree.  This would be the last video I'd want prospect patients to see.  I wonder what caused the X legs?
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: KrP1 on February 05, 2023, 10:55:59 AM
Can you provide more details? There is one diary here of an Australian patient who did his femur lengthening with Dr. Suhas Shah which went uneventfully.

First, there was a forum member, crimsontide, this doctor did atl surgery on him with very bad results. I know about other female patient, but i can't post info about her in the forum. She did her surgery with this doctor and ended with serious problems.
Title: Re: Dr Suhas Shah (Mumbai, India) Ashwinii Accident Hospital
Post by: sphenopetroclival on May 07, 2023, 12:35:25 PM
Okay so I just got off the phone with Dr. Shah (his assistant answered at first and, ironically, speaks not a word of English lol).
Dr. Shah states that the total cost of lengthening with the Precise 2 nail, including all hospital fees and one week's stay in the hospital, is $40,000USD (FORTY THOUSAND DOLLARS!). He also gives his patients the option of going home (in my case Canada) to lengthen, returning to India only to have the nail locked and to return the transponder. Of course there is the additional surgery to remove the nails 1 to 2 years after the initial surgery (the cost of which I stupidly forgot to ask him). I think this is great news! He claims he has "done this procedure before", but I wasn't able to obtain a figure as to how many times. I'm doing my tibias in January, but if this price remains the same in a year or two (wishful thinking), I'll be going there for my femurs.

the precice nail doesn't need to be "locked" and the ERC can be returned via mail to NuVasive.